The Ultimate Climbing Gear Guide: Types of Belay Devices

First go

Every belay device on the shop wall promises to hold a fall, and most of them look like a small lump of metal with a slot or two in it.

There are four main types of belay devices: the plain tube, the grooved tube with a high-friction side, the guide-mode tube that can also belay from the anchor, and the assisted braking device, like the GriGri. The figure of eight makes five, but it was designed for abseiling. None of them holds a fall without your brake hand on the rope.

Below is what each type does, what it is good for and which to get first. If you know the 2012 version of this guide, the names have changed, and the table matches the old ones to today’s.

What does a belay device actually do?

A belay device is a mechanical bit of kit that helps the belayer hold a fall. There are many types around today, and they all work on the same basic principle. They add friction into the system when it is needed, so no more rope is paid out to the climber and they are stopped before they hit the ground.

The BMC puts it neatly. The device magnifies the force of your grip on the free end of the rope, by bending and pinching the rope and through friction between the rope and the device. It clips to the belay loop of your harness with a locking karabiner, and our harness guide explains that loop.

That is what lets a smaller belayer hold a bigger climber at all, as the American Alpine Club points out. But no device makes weight stop mattering. Mammut says the weight ratio between belayer and climber directly affects how a fall gets caught, and the German Alpine Club (DAV) tells its indoor course students that on a top rope the climber must not weigh more than 1.5 times the belayer.

So if your climber is much heavier than you, deal with it before they leave the ground, whatever the device. Our lead belay guide covers that check.

What are the types of belay devices?

Here they are side by side.

TypeIn the 2012 guideGood forWatch out for
TubeTraditional Sticht or through deviceBelaying and abseiling. Light, and many take half and twin ropesBrakes only as well as your brake hand. Takes getting used to
Grooved tubeAssisted locking deviceMore holding power, especially on thinner ropesThe manual says which side suits your rope
Guide-mode tubeMulti function deviceEverything a tube does, plus belaying one or two seconds from the anchorGuide mode is an advanced technique to learn in person
Assisted braking deviceSemi automatic deviceThe climbing wall and sport climbing on a single ropeIt is not automatic. The brake hand never leaves the rope
Figure of eightOthersAbseilingRelatively low braking force when used to belay

Table: The five types of belay device, and their names in the 2012 version of this guide.

How does a tube device brake?

Tubes are the simplest devices of the lot. A bight of rope goes through a slot and clips to your harness with a locking karabiner, so the rope has to bend its way through. When the climber falls, you hold the brake rope down, which adds another bend as the rope comes out of the device. That extra bend, together with your grip, is what holds the fall.

Edelrid calls this the double-kink principle, the rope deflected once round the karabiner and once downwards over the device. Wild Country’s instructions for the VC Pro II describe the same thing as a “Z” shape, controlled by the angle and the force of the belayer’s grip.

A Black Diamond ATC, a tube-style belay device

The advantages are that tubes are very light and can be used for lots of things, like abseiling. Many take two ropes as well as one, the BMC points out, so they work with half and twin ropes too.

The disadvantages are that they take a little bit of getting used to before you can use one safely, and they don’t produce as much friction as some other devices, which can make a fall harder to hold.

What is a grooved tube?

Grooved tubes work the same way as plain tubes and look fairly similar. The difference is the “teeth” or grooves on one side of the device, which put more friction on the rope and the system. Makers now sell them as tubes with two friction modes, and you will hear them called grooved or high-friction tubes.

Wild Country’s instructions for the VC Pro II pictured below say its ribbed slots increase the holding power for more control on thinner ropes, while the smooth slots give a more dynamic belay on ropes of normal diameter. The BMC calls two modes like this useful for a device used with different rope diameters.

A Wild Country VC Pro II grooved tube belay device

So the advantages are that a fall is even easier to hold, the device is still fairly light, and most can be used with the rope going the other way, which makes it essentially a plain tube with less friction. That is sometimes useful for abseiling. Always check the device’s manual for which side suits your rope.

The disadvantages are the same as a tube. It takes getting used to, and a great deal of supervision is needed when you are first learning to use one.

What is guide mode?

Guide-mode tubes are similar to grooved tubes, with another feature added on. As well as belaying from your harness, you can attach the device straight to the anchor at the top of a pitch and belay your second from there. The 2012 guide called this using it as a “magic plate”.

Black Diamond and the BMC both describe guide mode as belaying one or two seconds from the anchor, and the BMC calls it useful for mountaineering and for climbing as a team of three. Petzl’s instructions for the Reverso call it assisted-braking belaying for one or two seconds.

A Petzl Reverso 3 tube belay device, the kind with a guide mode for belaying from the anchor

Don’t worry if that is new to you. It is a slightly more advanced technique for certain situations, and one to learn in person. Even in guide mode, Petzl’s instructions say to always hold the brake side of the rope, and they list ways the assisted braking can be disabled, such as a very thin rope crossing over itself.

So these devices are about as versatile as it gets.

What is an assisted braking device?

These are the 2012 guide’s semi automatic devices. Black Diamond, Edelrid and the BMC now call them assisted braking devices, and Petzl calls the GriGri a belay device with cam-assisted blocking.

They are designed to grab the rope when it is pulled sharply tight, as in a fall, but only with your brake hand doing its job. Petzl’s GriGri instructions say it is the hand on the brake side of the rope that makes the cam engage, and without it the rope tension may not be enough to start the device blocking.

They come in two kinds, and these are the BMC’s names for them.

  • Active devices have moving parts. The GriGri pictured below has a cam inside that rotates and pinches the rope.
  • Passive devices have no moving parts and brake through their shape. They look more like a tube, but a loaded rope gets pinched between the device and the karabiner. Edelrid’s Mega Jul is the BMC’s example.

The GriGri is certified to EN 15151-1, the European standard for braking devices with manually assisted locking. Manually is the word to notice.

A Petzl GriGri 2 assisted braking belay device

Assisted braking is a good thing, because it further reduces the effort needed to hold a fall and so lowers the chance of the climber being dropped. BUT it also carries a false sense of security. Because it “locks automatically”, it is often wrongly believed to be completely safe, and that you don’t need to hold on to the rope. That would be nice, but as with everything mechanical, it is not 100% foolproof. So take care, and never take the device’s capabilities for granted.

Assisted braking does not mean hands off

An assisted braking device is not automatic. Your brake hand never leaves the rope. Petzl’s instructions for the GriGri say to always hold the brake side of the rope, because if it is not held there is a risk the device will not block the rope, and the climber could hit the ground. The BMC is just as plain. “Brake hand low, don’t let go” applies to assisted braking devices, it says, always.

This guide is about choosing and understanding belay devices, not using them. Belaying is learned in person, from a qualified instructor or at your climbing wall. Petzl’s GriGri instructions say you must be specifically skilled in belay techniques before you use one.

Can you belay with a figure of eight?

The figure of eight is primarily an abseil device. It can be used for belaying, but the 2012 guide’s “very effectively” was too generous.

Black Diamond’s instructions for the Super 8 pictured below say it is designed as an abseil device in the traditional figure of eight mode, and that it can also work as a belay plate using the small hole. Edelrid says figure eights only achieve relatively low braking forces compared with other belay devices, especially on new or thin ropes, though they are handy for canyoning and mountaineering on wet ropes. So a figure of eight will belay, but it is not what it was designed for.

A Black Diamond Super 8 figure of eight abseil device

Which belay device should you get?

It depends where you climb and on what rope, so here is the advice by type, not brand.

  • For the climbing wall and sport climbing, an assisted braking device. The BMC says they are most suitable for indoor and sport climbing, and the German Alpine Club recommends them on its indoor courses. Most take a single rope only.
  • For trad and multi-pitch on half or twin ropes, a tube, since many take two ropes as well as one.
  • For mountaineering, climbing as a three, or bringing seconds up from the top of a pitch, a guide-mode tube.

Whichever type you choose, two things matter more than the brand. Match the device to your rope. The BMC calls this paramount, and the maker gives the rope range for every device. Our guide to climbing ropes explains single, half and twin ropes. Use a device you know. The DAV’s rule is to belay only with certified devices you are familiar with, and the BMC’s guide to assisted braking devices suggests trying one at your local climbing wall or shop before you buy.

As I said in the original guide, I think assisted braking devices are great for beginners and groups to use. That only holds alongside the warning above. They are not automatic, and the brake hand never leaves the rope.

This is not a tutorial on how to belay, just a guide to the different types of device out there and what they are good for. When you are ready to learn, start in person, then our guides to how to lead belay and tying off a belay plate pick up from there.

Where this sits in the gear guide

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main types of belay devices?

Tubes, grooved tubes with a high-friction side, guide-mode tubes that can also belay from the anchor, and assisted braking devices like the GriGri. The figure of eight is a fifth, but it was designed for abseiling and gives relatively low braking forces when used to belay.

Is a GriGri automatic?

No. It is an assisted braking device, not an automatic one. Petzl’s instructions say to always hold the brake side of the rope, because if it is not held the device may not block the rope.

What is the difference between active and passive assisted braking devices?

Active devices, like the GriGri, have moving parts, a cam that rotates and pinches the rope. Passive devices have no moving parts and pinch the rope against the karabiner through their shape. Both still need your brake hand on the rope.

Which type of belay device is best for beginners?

For the climbing wall and sport climbing, an assisted braking device, which the BMC says suits indoor and sport climbing best. Whatever you choose, belay only with a device you are familiar with, and never treat it as automatic.

Can a light belayer hold a heavy climber?

The device helps, but it does not make weight stop mattering. Mammut says the weight ratio directly affects how a fall gets caught, and the German Alpine Club’s limit on a top rope is a climber no more than 1.5 times the belayer’s weight.

In short

Every type of belay device magnifies the grip of your brake hand rather than replacing it, so pick the type for where you climb, match it to your rope, and never let go of the brake side.

If you are buying your first one, try the type you want at your wall or a climbing shop first, and learn to belay with it in person.

Ask any questions in the comments below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top